Redaction s note.

 And about a question for legal  liability by Igor is not answered, but his answer maybe  is his certification, that he it not takes  births. And  from the speeches.

 Professor Chernuha, am not seen in data materials a science base, not a see tactical  material.To reviews for method a birth managing in water, as by posts from a popular press,  we are as scientists not having rights. A movie showed to us , but he is not science, he is advertisement  And what about a medical aspect, thus for example, am having diploma as professor , am never will agree,to take births in water.  

Friend from auditorium: is not called name, as am not having medical education, as am not gynaecologist am as physicist. But a m taken birth in my wife at water as in bath, its a good all visible, and births are natural process  ,that we cannot visit toilet with someone s control.

Redaction s note.

 So we are managing for documental speech and again I want left this protocol. And to comment a last performance. And,   people's going for risk in both cases, or an other exit is not having, or this is not dangerous. And,  a how not professional to know ,that specialists are knowing , that taken many births, and a how unpredictable are suddenly as a hard complication .

 Professor Ivanov :Am working for 40 years as gynaecologist-obstetrician, as 25 years am managing for pathology region a pregnancy and all of my experience confirms ,that as a managing for birth as by Charkovsky is not allowed! As its said , that in birth in water , baby enters in environment ,to which is he habit. Thus,  in mum s belly embryo staying in sterile  biologically active environment, as constantly changing.Its  a not simple water or salt solution, a how to compare this environment with water in bath?And,  if in water in women beginning bleeding, she can to  dead for 5 min. And in pregnancy having cardiovascular diseases, kidneys and other organs ,thus a good doctor s checking allowing preventing these unfavourable results. And,  a how at home in water birth? Its a happy, that never happened catastrophe.

 Professor Filimonov:Igor Borisovich  is lined on a famous scientist , but why?And , not need this  to producing  as impressing for speculation.